How Is Mental Illness Treated?
The first section of the chapter presents the principles of
the major approaches to treatment. Historically, much of what
was done in psychotherapy was based on the practitioner's
theoretical orientation. One's views about the causes
of psychological disorders heavily influenced one's
approach and the techniques used.
| Table 17.1: Treatment Theories |
| Approach to Treatment |
Basic Principles of Treatment |
 |
| Psychodynamic |
uncover unconscious conflicts that give
rise to maladaptive behaviors |
| Humanistic |
help people fulfill potential for growth
through self-understanding |
| Behavioral |
maladaptive behavior is unlearned through
conditioning principles |
| Cognitive-behavioral |
eliminate distorted thoughts that cause
maladaptive behaviors |
| Group |
use group for social skills, interpersonal
learning, and social support |
| Systems |
improve family interactions as issues arise
in larger social context |
| Biological |
directly treat abnormalities in neural
and bodily processes |
 |
 |
Psychodynamic therapists employ free association and
dream analysis to achieve insight about unconscious
influences. Humanistic therapists use reflective listening
as in client-centered therapy to facilitate greater
self-understanding and personal growth. Behavioral therapists
use specific techniques such as social-skills training
and systematic desensitization to learn more adaptive
behavior through the principles of operant and classical conditioning.
Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) incorporates these learning
principles as well as addresses the faulty cognitions that
lead to maladaptive behaviors and emotions.
Practitioners from different theoretical approaches use the
social support and interpersonal learning found in group therapy
to address their clients' issues. The systems approach
to psychotherapy considers that one's individual problems
arise in a larger family context and that one must address
how the family interacts to achieve a more durable result.
Finally, biological therapies recognize that some psychological
disorders result from abnormalities in neural and bodily processes.
They attempt to change these processes, most commonly through
the use of psychotropic medications such as antianxiety
drugs, antidepressants, and antipsychotics.
It is noteworthy that numerous research studies have found
these approaches to be effective. It is equally interesting
that, overall, no one approach has been found to be clearly
superior to the others. Part of this may be attributable to
the fact that there are some common factors that contribute
to the effectiveness of all approaches despite the specific
techniques used. Common factors include a strong relationship
between the therapist and client and the powerful emotional
reaction of confession (i.e., catharsis).
What Are the Most Effective Treatments?
The next section presents research findings on what are the
most effective treatments for anxiety, mood, and schizophrenic
disorders. One of the major changes in psychological treatment
in recent years has been the shift of therapists from an allegiance
to one approach to the more eclectic use of multiple approaches,
depending on the person and problem. For specific phobias,
behavioral techniques based on exposure (e.g., systematic
desensitization) are the treatment of choice. CBT and
medication (e.g., imipramine) have been found to be
useful in the treatment of panic disorder. For those who have
panic disorder with agoraphobia, the combination of CBT and
drugs is significantly better than either treatment alone.
CBT and medication (e.g., clomipramine) have also been
helpful in the treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder
(OCD). Exposure and response prevention are
the critical components of the behavioral intervention for
OCD.
There are multiple effective treatments for the mood disorders.
For depression, several classes of medication have been found
to be effective including monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors,
tricyclics, and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors
(SSRIs). The SSRIs, including Prozac, are used more frequently
as they tend to result in fewer side effects. For depression,
results from cognitive behavioral therapy and treatment with
medication are equal, which gives clients a choice based on
individual preference. CBT attacks the distorted cognitions
that result in negative mood. Some recent studies suggest
that
combining CBT and antidepressants is more effective than either
approach alone. Phototherapy, exposure to high-intensity
light, is effective in the treatment of seasonal affective
disorder.
For more severe treatment-resistant forms of depression, electroconvulsive
therapy (ECT) has been a last resort. More recently, transcranial
magnetic stimulation (TMS) has been proposed as an alternative
to ECT and medication. Thus far, it appears that TMS is
more
effective for nonpsychotic depression, whereas ECT is more
effective for psychotic depression. For individuals with
bipolar disorder,
the choice of treatment is clear—the drug lithium
has far surpassed other approaches.
Can Personality Disorders Be Treated?
Since personality disorders are, by definition, chronic maladaptive
ways of interacting with the world, they are extremely difficult
to treat. Individuals with these disorders tend to see the
environment rather than their own behaviors as the cause of
their problems, thus they are unmotivated to change. Treatments
for two well-researched personality disorders are presented.
Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) has been the most
successful treatment program to date for borderline personality
disorder. In DBT, the therapist targets the client's
most extreme and dysfunctional behaviors, explores past traumatic
experiences that may be at the root of emotional problems,
and facilitates the development of self-respect and independent
problem solving. Despite many varied attempts, little has
been found to help individuals with antisocial personality
disorder. One can hope for a reduction in antisocial behaviors
after age 40, perhaps due to a reduction in biological drives.
It appears that efforts in this area are better spent in prevention
and support for the individual's family.
How Should Childhood Disorders Be Treated?
The final section of the chapter looks at treatments for two
of the childhood disorders. Although autism is considered
a biological disorder, biological interventions have been
largely ineffective. Autistic children seem to benefit the
most from highly structured behavioral therapies based on
principles of operant conditioning; however, the long-term
prognosis for autism remains poor. More options are available
for children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
(ADHD). Pharmacological treatment (e.g., methylphenidate)
is beneficial for many; however, its use has sparked much
controversy. As with most medications, Ritalin is not a magic
bullet that removes all problems. Its effect is significantly
enhanced when children also receive some type of behavior
modification. Recent research indicates that medication plus
behavioral therapy is more effective in treating ADHD than
either treatment approach alone. |