How Are Mental Disorders Conceptualized
and Classified?
The chapter begins with a consideration of how disorders are
conceptualized and classified. Again, abnormality is a cultural
judgment, and particular behaviors may be seen as deviant
in one society but unremarkable in another. In American society,
the symptoms of a disorder must interfere with a least one
aspect of a person's life—such as work, social
relations, and self-care. Health care professionals use the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
(DSM-IV) to identify psychological disorders. The DSM has
been around for more than 50 years, and in its current fourth
edition, psychopathology is described in terms of observable
symptoms. Individuals are diagnosed on a multiaxial
scale, including clinical syndromes, personality disorders,
general medical conditions, psychosocial stressors, and
global assessment of functioning. However, the DSM-IV
gives little information about the cause, prognosis, or treatment
of disorders.
The authors review some of the classic models of psychopathology
(psychoanalytic, family systems, sociocultural, cognitive-behavioral).
Most ideas of cause involve multiple factors and incorporate
some aspect of the diathesis-stress model. This is
the idea that disorders are the result of an underlying predisposition
(diathesis) which is made evident by environmental stress.
Finally, the authors look at the differences between the
psychological concept of mental disorders and the legal concept
of insanity. Most people mistakenly believe that the
insanity defense is a common strategy to avoid criminal prosecution.
In actuality, competency to stand trial is a more common
area in which one's mental functioning comes into question.
| Table 16.1: Definitions
of Insanity |
| Insanity Rule |
Definition |
 |
| M'Naughten |
person does not know right from wrong |
| Durham |
behavior is the result of mental illness
or mental defect |
| American Law Institute |
mental illness or defect led to a lack
of capacity to appreciate the criminality of the act or
to an inability to conform to the law |
 |
 |
Can Anxiety Be the Root of Seemingly
Different Disorders?
The next section begins the consideration of specific psychological
disorders. The anxiety disorders are characterized
by excessive anxiety in the absence of true danger. Within
this category, the phobias involve excessive fear of
a specific object or situation. Most students will be familiar
with specific phobias (e.g, claustrophobia, acrophobia,
hydrophobia) that involve discrete events or objects. Most
students also will have empathy for the social phobias
which involve the fear of being negatively evaluated by others,
fear of public speaking, and fear of eating in front of others.
Individuals with generalized anxiety disorder are
constantly anxious and worry about trivial matters. Panic
disorder involves sudden and overwhelming attacks of terror
and often results in agoraphobia, the fear of being
in a public situation from which escape is difficult. Obsessive-compulsive
disorder (OCD) involves intrusive thoughts that are dealt
with through maladaptive, repetitive actions. Numerous theories
have been proposed to explain the anxiety disorders, and they
certainly involve the cognitive misperceptions of actual danger.
Recent advances in neurophysiology have related obsessive-compulsive
disorder to dysfunction in the caudate nucleus and
panic disorder to abnormality in the locus coeruleus.
Are Mood Disorders Extreme Manifestations
of Normal Mood?
The mood disorders, which involve extreme emotions,
include one of the most common diagnostic categories—major
depression. Individuals with this disorder show symptoms
such as depressed mood, loss of interest in pleasurable activities,
weight changes, sleep disturbances, difficulty concentrating,
guilt, and suicidal ideation. A milder form of depression,
dysthymia, involves depressed mood for at least 2 years.
Moods can also swing from depression to mania, as is
seen in bipolar disorder, or from mild depression to
hypomania, as is seen in cyclothymia. A strong
genetic component has been implicated in bipolar disorder.
A genetic component has been found for major depression also,
but it has not been as strong.
Major depression has been linked to the neurotransmitters
norepinephrine and serotonin. Indeed, medications
such as Prozac that selectively increase serotonin have had
a huge impact on treatment since the early 1990s. Depression
has also been associated with maladaptive cognitions (e.g.,
Beck's cognitive triad), errors in logic,
and learned helplessness. Finally, life stressors
can precipitate an episode of major depression; however, the
effects of these events can be attenuated by the presence
of close friends
Is Schizophrenia a Disorder of Mind or
Body?
Schizophrenia is one of the most devastating of all
the mental disorders in terms of its effect on the victim
and family. Although it often is erroneously referred to as
“split personality,” the splitting in schizophrenia
is between thought and emotion. Schizophrenia is a psychotic
disorder, characterized by alterations in thought, perceptions,
or consciousness. The rate of schizophrenia in the population
is about 1% and has remained relatively stable across time
and among cultures. Although the DSM-IV lists various subtypes
of schizophrenia (paranoid, disorganized, catatonic, undifferentiated,
residual), they can also be classified by positive and
negative symptoms. The positive symptoms of schizophrenia
involve excesses of behavior and include delusions, hallucinations,
and loosening of associations. The negative symptoms of
schizophrenia involve deficits in functioning and include
isolation, withdrawal, and apathy. Schizophrenia
has a strong biological component, and the positive symptoms
often are dramatically reduced by antipsychotic medication.
Unfortunately, the negative symptoms of schizophrenia tend
to persist, which has led investigators to hypothesize that
this form of schizophrenia is related to structural brain
abnormalities. One recent hypothesis regarding the cause of
schizophrenia is that it is related to a slow-acting virus
that becomes evident in symptomatology when an individual
reaches young adulthood.
Are Personality Disorders Truly Mental
Disorders?
The personality disorders are a controversial category
of disorders marked by inflexible and maladaptive ways of
interacting with the world. While the DSM-IV lists three categories
of personality disorders by general behavior (odd/eccentric,
dramatic/emotional/erratic, anxious/fearful), there is
considerable overlap among the traits in the individual disorders.
This has led to a reduction in reliability of diagnosis. Two
of the personality disorders that have received considerable
research investigation are borderline personality disorder
and antisocial personality disorder.
Borderline personality disorder is characterized by a poor
sense of self, emotional instability, and impulsivity. These
individuals can be very dramatic and exhibit self-mutilation
or suicidal behaviors. Borderline personality disorder has
been linked to low serotonin levels and a history of physical
and/or sexual abuse. Individuals with antisocial personality
disorder demonstrate little empathy for others or remorse
for their self-gratifying behaviors. This disorder is seen
frequently in prison populations and has been related to low
levels of arousal, poor response to punishment, and deficits
in frontal lobe functioning.
Should Childhood Disorders Be Considered
a Unique Category?
The final category, childhood disorders, remains controversial,
because children show varied rates of development. What is
seen as abnormal at one stage may be normal at another. Autism
is a severe childhood disorder characterized by deficits in
social interaction, impaired communication, and restricted
interests. It is hard to believe that not long ago this disorder
was associated with poor parenting; whereas, today it is understood
to have a largely biological cause. Genetic and neurochemical
research appears to have tremendous promise in improving our
understanding and treatment of autistic behaviors.
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) has
received considerable research and media attention in recent
years. ADHD children are characterized by restlessness, inattention,
and impulsivity. The unfortunate aspect of these symptoms
is that they are associated with academic, social, and vocational
underachievement. ADHD has been related to poor parenting
and sociocultural factors; however, there also is a clear
genetic component. Noted deficits in functioning in the frontolimbic
system and caudate nucleus provide potential areas for future
treatments.
|