Assessing Logical Strength
Assessing Arguments with Dependent Premises

When there are dependent premises, the argument is only as strong as its weakest premise.

Example:

Consider the following argument:

1. People have a right to self-defense.
2. Gun control violates the right of self-defense.
3. Therefore, the government should not restrict gun ownership.

In this argument, 1 and 2 jointly support 3. However, 1 seems to be stronger than 2, so the argument is only as strong as 2 is.


Independent Premises | Dependent Premises | Multistep Arguments

Assessing Logical Strength

© Copyright 1998, W.W. Norton & Co.