Chapter 26
Chapter 26: The Modern Temper
Chapter Outline
I. Reaction in the twenties
- After World War I, America was seen by many as crumbling culturally. This belief led to confusion among Americans and radical reactions to 19th century cultural assumptions.
- Nativism
- Immigration led to early 20th century fears of immigrant radicalism-a threat to the established social order. By 1920, immigrants became the majority of white factory workers.
- Sacco and Vanzetti
- Arrested for robbery and murder
- Their main crime might have been their political beliefs combined with their immigrant status
- Executed despite public demonstrations on their behalf
- Immigration restriction
- Emergency Immigration Act of 1921 limited immigration
- Influence of racist pseudo-scientific studies
- New immigration quota law in 1924 favored old immigration from northern and western Europe and excluded Asians.
- New law allowed unrestricted immigration from Western Hemisphere countries making Latinos the fastest growing ethnic minority
- The Klan
- Unlike predecessor, devoted to "100% Americanism." TargetedAfrica-Americans, but also Roman Catholics, Jews, and immigrants.
- The founding and early years of the new Klan; no longer confined to the South
- Reaction to shifting moral standards, decline of church's authority and broad-mindedness of city dwellers and college students
- Internal dissent and violent methods caused the decline of the Klan
- Fundamentalism
- Rise of "modern" Christianity and the reaction to that notion
- William Jennings Bryan and other leaders against the teaching of evolution
- 1925, The Scopes "Monkey" Trial in Dayton, Tennessee, over teaching of evolution in public schools and colleges
- The Tennessee antievolution law and the civil boosters of Dayton
- Bryan, Clarence Darrow, and the trial
- Death of Bryan and the decline of fundamentalism
- Prohibition
- Reasons for push for Prohibition: moral righteousness and social conformity
- Early prohibition movements: WCTU and Anti-Saloon League-rhetoric contains virulent ethnic and social prejudice and seems aimed at policing the poor, the foreign born, and the working class
- Eighteenth Amendment ratified in 1919
- Problems of enforcement
- Congress did not allocate adequate enforcement resources
- Illegal stills and rum-running
- Speakeasies
- Organized crime
- Prohibition gave new source of income and encouraged political corruption
- Auto and machine gun provide mobility and firepower
- Al Capone and Eliot Ness
II. The Roaring Twenties
- Defensive temper of the 1920s partly a reaction to social and intellectual Revolution-cosmopolitan urban America confronts insular, rural America
- The Jazz Age
- Scott Fitzgerald named it and the music spawned new forms of recreation and sexuality
- New dances like the Charleston shocked guardians of morality
- The New Morality
- Young people lead a revolution in manners and morals
- F . Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise documents the change-the "petting party," bathtub gin, promiscuity and more
- The New Woman
- Growing awareness of Sigmund Freud's theories prompted discussion of sex
- Fashion fights prudishness-the flapper
- Margaret Sanger and Birth Control
- Sanger a nurse among the poor and recognizes need for family planning-distributes literature advising women to take control of their bodies
- She forms The Birth Control League targeting doctors, social workers and scientists as well as working-class women
- Lost support when she advocated sterilization for the mentally incompetent and those with certain genetic disorders
- "Every child a wanted child"
- The Women's Movement
- Suffrage movement
- Alice Paul, the National American Woman Suffrage Association
- Paul, Lucy Burns, and the Congressional Union for Woman Suffrage-first suggestion of Constitutional Amendment
- Paul and the National Woman's Party-picketing and civil disobedience
- After vacillating, Woodrow Wilson proposes states allow women to vote; addresses NAWSA and works for woman suffrage
- Arguments for woman suffrage
- the right to vote and hold office is simple justice
- women are morally superior to men
- women are less prone to war
- women would promote society's welfare-an engine for Progressive social change
- Women's Movement not immune from era's prejudice
- Carrie Chapman Catt warns of danger from poor and ethnic votes
- Southerners say womens' votes would insure white supremacy
- Wilson embraces the "Susan B. Anthony Amendment"
- Nineteenth Amendment ratified in 1920
- The Equal Rights Amendment
- Promoted by Alice Paul
- Introduced in Congress in 1923
- Congress did not adopt amendment until 1972; it then failed ratification
- Working women
- Increases in number of working women
- Most still in traditional occupations
- The "New Negro"
- In the Great Migration of African Americans, nearly 1 million of the South's native blacks moved north; political influence followed
- The Harlem Renaissance
- Literary and artistic awakening among African-Americans
- A rediscovery of black folk culture and bolder treatment of controversial topics
- Writers of the Harlem Renaissance-Claude McKay, Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston, Countee Cullen, James Weldon Johnson
- Cane by Jean Toomer
- Negro nationalism
- Promoted black cultural expression and black exclusiveness
- Marcus Garvey the leading spokesman
- Universal Negro Improvement Association (UNIA)
- African-Americans were to liberate themselves from white culture
- Appalled W. E. B. DuBois
- Garvey advocated return to Africa
- Prison, obscure death in London
- The NAACP
- Organized in 1910 by white progressives and black activists
- Main strategy of NAACP was education and legal action
- 1919 attack on lynching
III. The culture of modernism
- Science and social thought
- Isaac Newton's universe had been an ordered one, knowable by the human mind; an infinite progress in knowledge seemed possible
- The work of Albert Einstein showed that everything is relative
- Max Planck and quantum theory-atoms more complex that previously believed
- Werner Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle indicated that human knowledge of the universe is limited-the observer changes what is being observed
- Relativity and uncertainty undermine traditional values of personal responsibility and absolute standards
- "Culture" changes from refinement to the product of human endeavor; thus, all societies exhibit culture and no one is better than another.
- Ruth Benedict and Margaret Mead
- Modernist Art and Literature
- "All that is solid melts into air"-reality was not to be accepted, but created; subconscious more interesting than reason
- Modernism applied
- Abstract painting
- atonal music
- free verse
- stream-of-consciousness
- Bohemian culture in New York and Chicago
- Armory show shocks audiences
- Ex-patriots lead literary modernism from outside the U.S.
- Ezra Pound
- T. S. Eliot
- Gertrude Stein
- James Joyce
- F. Scott Fitzgerald
- Ernest Hemingway
- The Southern Renaissance
- The south a mythic world in the process of rebirth
- Angered the Klan and traditionalists, but inspired young writers
- Thomas Wolfe
- William Faulkner